Supply chains have spent years improving visibility. Systems are more connected, dashboards are richer, data is arriving faster and AI is creating new ways to analyse information.
But are organisations making better decisions as a result?
More information can help businesses respond faster, but it can also create noise, competing interpretations and uncertainty about when to act. Better decisions depend on knowing what matters, whether the information can be trusted and when there is enough to act.
For supply chain specialist recruitment firm Bastian, this raises an important question about the skills and capabilities organisations need in their supply chain leaders. To explore this, Bastian sought insights from three experienced industry leaders on what it takes to turn information into better decisions.
Start with the decision, not the data
For Alice Brimicombe, Business Development Director at DMS and President of the ASCLA NSW Division, the starting point is understanding what decision needs to be made.
More data doesn’t necessarily mean better decisions, you need the right data.
Alice Brimicombe, Business Development Director at DMS and President of the ASCLA NSW Division
She points to DMS client Farmlands, New Zealand’s largest rural co-operative, where more than 350,000 purchase orders and 1.5 million line items were being processed manually each year. By moving to exception-led planning, only around 1–2% of SKUs required planner attention, while product availability increased from 80% to over 95%.
The example demonstrates the value of identifying which information requires attention rather than treating every data point as equally important.
But there is also a point at which leaders need to stop analysing and act.
“What separates them for me is knowing when you have enough information to decide, rather than continuing to analyse and waiting for perfect information.”
Can you trust what you’re seeing?
Darren Wedding, former Chief Supply Chain Officer at MYER and Super Retail Group, believes another challenge is turning data from different systems and formats into information that leaders can confidently use.
That requires understanding the difference between lag indicators, which show what has already happened, and lead indicators that can help anticipate what comes next.
It also requires trust in the information itself.
We also need to have established a process in advance to validate the accuracy of the data we are receiving so that we don’t simply question the information when it arrives and instead have sufficient trust to act.
Darren Wedding, former Chief Supply Chain Officer at MYER and Super Retail Group
Darren compares this to understanding how a truck operates. Before relying on its dashboard, a leader needs to understand what is happening under the bonnet and ensure their team does too.
The same principle applies to supply chain data. Leaders do not need to become data scientists, but they do need to understand where information comes from, how it is produced and its limitations.
As Darren explains:
“Data and information is never perfect and in many cases it is the experience of the team supported by the data that aids decision making.”
At some point, someone has to make the call
Even relevant and trusted information does not automatically lead to action.
For Jon Adams, Executive GM Supply Chain & Procurement at Bapcor Limited, the next challenge is prioritisation and follow-through.
“The biggest gap between having the information and being able to turn it into meaningful action is the same as its always been – the ability to ruthlessly prioritise and then create a culture and cadence to follow through relentlessly.”
AI can accelerate analysis and make information available faster, but that speed only creates value when leaders remain focused on the right decisions.
Jon also believes leaders need to be comfortable acting without complete certainty.
I strongly believe the maxim that it’s better to make more decisions than less – even if you get some wrong – as long as you learn from it.
Jon Adams, Executive GM Supply Chain & Procurement at Bapcor Limited
This is particularly relevant as supply chains become more complex. Technology can support decisions, but accountability for making them still sits with people.
What does this mean for supply chain leadership?
The insights shared by Alice, Darren and Jon highlight an important consideration for organisations recruiting supply chain leaders. While technology capabilities are becoming increasingly valuable, they cannot replace the fundamentals of leadership.
Today’s supply chain leaders need to interpret information, challenge assumptions, prioritise effectively and make decisions under pressure. They also need the people skills to bring their teams along with them.
Jon cautions against placing too much emphasis on technology expertise at the expense of these capabilities.
“The market can get carried away with those who fully embrace new technologies but perhaps is more willing to forgive those who lack key people and process skills. Both are required.”
Darren highlights curiosity as another essential quality. Strong leaders should want to understand how systems work, where information comes from and whether the results make sense.
Without curiosity however you might simply blindly accept the data and never challenge the status quo.
Darren Wedding, former Chief Supply Chain Officer at MYER and Super Retail Group
As AI makes it easier to generate answers, the ability to ask the right questions and recognise when something does not add up becomes increasingly valuable.
For organisations recruiting their next supply chain leader, Bastian believes the priority should be finding someone who combines technological understanding with sound judgement, curiosity and the confidence to act.
The perspectives shared by Alice, Darren and Jon reinforce that better decisions do not necessarily come from having more information. They come from knowing what matters, trusting the information available and having the leadership skills to act on it.
Visibility gives a supply chain the ability to see what is happening. Leadership determines what happens next.
Learn more about Bastian Consulting International: bconsult.io